Press play to hearken to this text
In a show of what is perhaps referred to as certified solidarity, most EU international locations rebuffed a tantrum over coronavirus vaccine distribution led by Austrian Chancellor Sebastian Kurz, and agreed Thursday to provide further doses to 5 nations hit hardest by the pandemic.
The choice taken by EU ambassadors successfully reaffirmed the EU’s present population-based vaccine allocation formulation, and delivered an embarrassing defeat to Kurz, in addition to Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babiš and Slovenian Prime Minister Janez Janša.
Austria, the Czech Republic and Slovenia all refused to take part within the plan, put ahead by the Portuguese presidency of the Council of the EU, to assist the hard-hit international locations: Bulgaria, Croatia, Estonia, Latvia and Slovakia.
The place taken by Babiš appeared notably self-defeating as a result of it resulted within the Czech Republic forfeiting some 140,000 further doses that it might have acquired below the Portuguese plan as a result of it might have certified for further help.
For Janša, whose nation takes over the rotating Council presidency on July 1, it was a reasonably inauspicious show of obvious selfishness and unwillingness to affix within the community-minded disaster administration that Brussels considers to be the EU’s most interesting attribute.
And for Kurz, the ringleader of the trouble to interrupt the pro-rata allocation formulation, it marked a failure on a number of fronts. He was unable to safe any extra vaccine doses for his nation; he betrayed the needy international locations that originally supported his efforts; and he undercut his personal aspirations of turning into a frontrunner of Europe’s dominant center-right political household.
One senior diplomat mentioned that Kurz’s affect and credibility had been “severely broken” by the episode, by which the Austrian chief hijacked a European Council video summit final week to demand assist for needy international locations, however then refused to affix in offering such assist when Fee statistics confirmed that Austria itself was nowhere close to among the many worst-off. A second diplomat mentioned that Kurz was now “persona non grata” for many member international locations.
In a authorities assertion on Thursday night, Kurz falsely asserted that the EU had distributed vaccines unequally, and claimed credit score for highlighting the alleged drawback.
“Austria has drawn consideration to the issue of the unequal distribution of vaccines,” he mentioned within the assertion. “It’s good that this has been acknowledged within the EU and that the solidarity mechanism is meant to cut back this inequality within the distribution of vaccines for some severely affected international locations, comparable to Croatia and Bulgaria.”
His assertion didn’t point out that Austria fought the solidarity mechanism and refused to take part in it, however then claimed it was “incomprehensible” that the Czech Republic was not receiving further doses despite the fact that it was Vienna and Prague that fought the plan that may have offered extra vaccines.
Kurz mentioned Austria was “discussing” methods to assist the Czech Republic bilaterally, however made no particular dedication to take action.
Austria’s ‘personal fault’
Even earlier than the summit, Kurz had stoked a fierce combat over the allocation of vaccines, by which he tried in charge the Fee for an alleged short-changing of Austria. Actually, Kurz’s authorities was itself in charge for having declined to buy its full allotment of doses below the EU’s joint vaccine procurement program.
Different international locations had equally miscalculated nevertheless it was Kurz who tried to rally different leaders by overtly blaming Brussels for missteps made in his personal capital.
“It’s not stunning to any of us who’ve been in opposition for a very long time: Kurz usually sees the EU as a means to an finish of his personal political sport,” mentioned Claudia Gamon, an Austrian member of the European Parliament from the liberal Renew Europe group. “I feel there’s a correlation between him being in political bother at house and utilizing the EU as a scapegoat.”
Gamon famous that different features of the Fee’s vaccine technique may pretty deserve criticism however that the Austrian authorities had gambled and misplaced by choosing and selecting among the many menu of vaccines and never shopping for its full allotted share. “It’s merely our personal fault,” she mentioned. “That’s why he’s nervous.”
Because the battle intensified in latest days, Kurz was in touch with many leaders and on Thursday, there have been many contacts amongst officers from the six international locations that initially signed a letter demanding assist acquiring extra doses. In these contacts Vienna once more insisted on making an attempt to dam the choice, two diplomats mentioned. The opposition continued till the final second, with the gang of three even making an attempt to cease the choice of the others to go forward with the redistribution proposal till Council legal professionals made clear that EU international locations may do as they wished with their allotment of vaccines.
“The authorized service defined it was not potential as a result of it’s not a Council resolution that might be stopped. Member states are entitled to make use of their doses as they need,” one diplomat mentioned.
A second senior diplomat mentioned that Kurz had been unable to carry collectively his preliminary group of six.
“That coalition was launched by Kurz however with out prior session with the others,” the second senior diplomat mentioned. “And it has very quickly emerged that that they didn’t share the identical pursuits.”
“On the finish, no one may take any extra Kurz — his manner of doing issues,” a fourth diplomat mentioned. “His concept of solidarity à la carte proved to be insufferable for many people,” the diplomat added. “He launched this marketing campaign asking for extra solidarity and ended it denying solidarity to the others. I imagine it mentioned all of it.”
A 3rd senior diplomat chided the three international locations over their lack of solidarity: “EU solidarity shouldn’t be a sport of comfort. It’s a dedication. Regretfully, some member states determined to decide on cherry-picking and defending slender pursuits over long-term achieve for the whole bloc.”
A number of diplomats gave the Portuguese presidency credit score for skilfully navigating the dispute.
Pals in want
Finally week’s summit, heads of state and authorities rebuffed Kurz’s calls for for a higher share of an advance supply of 10 million vaccines, and so they reaffirmed the population-based allocation technique. However the leaders additionally tasked EU ambassadors to give you a plan for utilizing a few of these vaccines to assist the international locations in biggest want.
In an effort to hold out the leaders’ directions, the Portuguese presidency put ahead a plan to distribute 7 million doses in line with the prevailing formulation, whereas reserving 3 million doses for six hard-hit international locations, together with the Czech Republic. However Vienna, Prague and Ljubljana refused.
In a strong-arm tactic that additionally failed, Austria at one level even threatened to dam the Fee from transferring ahead with a broader buy possibility for 100 million doses of BioNTech/Pfizer vaccine.
As soon as it was clear that his calls for wouldn’t be met, Kurz turned in opposition to the Portuguese plan, which might have required Austria to donate a portion of its share of the three million doses to the needier nations. Kurz then insisted on sticking to the pro-rata formulation he had tried to dismantle, as a result of it might give his personal nation extra.
With Austria, the Czech Republic and Slovenia in opposition, the 19 different EU international locations agreed to behave on their very own to assist the neediest 5 nations use what was left of the three million doses after the opponents saved their pro-rata allotment.
Ultimately, the most important loser seemed to be Babiš, who in opposing the Portuguese plan appeared to have fallen on his personal syringe, so to talk.
Whereas refusing to affix the Portuguese plan gave Austria and Slovenia barely extra doses than if that they had participated within the donation effort, the Czechs would have acquired some 140,000 “solidarity” doses below the plan. Opting out resulted in a internet loss for the Czechs of 70,000 doses, diplomats mentioned. The lack of these doses may effectively come again to hang-out Babiš in nationwide elections this fall.
There was no instant rationalization for Prague’s transfer, which gave the impression to be rooted in a miscalculation that Austria’s ways would succeed.
“Babiš insists he’s not a standard politician,” mentioned a fourth senior diplomat. “However it’s exhausting to say precisely what it means when it comes to negotiations and what went so improper in Prague.”
A Czech diplomat mentioned it was improper to assume the nation had stood blindly with Kurz, and tried to spin Prague’s lack of vaccines as doubtlessly a needier nation’s achieve.
“We had been calling for solidarity nevertheless it didn’t come to everybody,” the diplomat mentioned. “It’s a false notion we’re sticking to somebody. We’re merely making an attempt to get extra solidarity for many who wanted it. On the finish, these doses that we’re not taking could find yourself going to those that want them much more.”
This text is a part of POLITICO’s premium coverage service: Professional Well being Care. From drug pricing, EMA, vaccines, pharma and extra, our specialised journalists maintain you on prime of the matters driving the well being care coverage agenda. E mail [email protected] for a complimentary trial.