Corbin Smith spent a number of weeks seemingly caught within the Dominican Republic — sleeping in a automotive, a hostel and a half-finished resort, all whereas a COVID-19 flight shutdown erected hurdles to getting again residence to Toronto.
However whether or not he wanted a crowdfunding marketing campaign to get residence relies on who you ask.
In response to Smith, his employer Enviroshake — an eco-friendly roofing materials firm — fired him in January for no obvious motive whereas he was on a piece journey, proper after Canada’s main airways suspended service to the Caribbean. He says that left him successfully stranded.
However Enviroshake mentioned Smith was fired for violating company insurance policies and was as a substitute in a “self-imposed exile” after refusing the corporate’s provide to fly him residence. Smith mentioned he acquired no such provide.
Complicating the problem is the truth that Smith’s father, Patrick Smith, is the president and co-owner of the corporate that fired his son. Neither these ties nor the alleged provide of a flight residence have been disclosed to the person who began a crowdfunding web page for Smith that generated $13,543 — a few of which Smith used to get residence.
That GoFundMe marketing campaign, which was extensively shared, was later paused by its organizer, who mentioned he was genuinely frightened for his buddy however is now pissed off by the lack of expertise he was given. With the organizer at nighttime, none of those points have been disclosed to individuals who donated.
Smith is now again in Canada, however many questions stay concerning the scenario.
Smith mentioned he was in the best, and credited the generosity of others with permitting him to get again to Canada.
“I am so lucky,” he instructed CBC Information in a WhatsApp message. “So many individuals got here out of the woodwork.”
In an interview, Smith mentioned he arrived within the Dominican Republic for work on Jan. 17, and was fired a few weeks later through e mail. He mentioned he was solely instructed it was “as a consequence of quite a few causes” with no different clarification given.
However in an e mail to CBC Information, Enviroshake’s vice-president of promoting and gross sales, Ashley Smith, who isn’t associated to Corbin, offered a distinct model of occasions.
Firm alleges Smith violated insurance policies
She mentioned on the finish of a two-week enterprise journey, Smith requested every week’s trip, which was authorized by his father, the corporate’s president.
“Throughout his trip, Mr. Smith engaged in a number of actions that violated Enviroshake’s insurance policies, together with the confidentiality and non-disparagement insurance policies,” she mentioned. Corbin Smith disputes these allegations.
The corporate alleged it tried to contact Smith through telephone, textual content message and e mail to inform him to cease allegedly breaching its insurance policies.
“Regardless of Enviroshake’s repeated efforts to speak with Mr. Smith, he was not responsive,” Ashley Smith mentioned. “Consequently, Enviroshake terminated Mr. Smith’s employment on a without-cause foundation.”
Ashley Smith mentioned the corporate determined in opposition to terminating Smith for simply trigger, as that might have resulted in no termination pay and prevented him from making use of for EI.
Regardless of firing him, Enviroshake provided to pay for Smith’s flight and canopy all of his quarantine bills, she mentioned. Smith’s father additionally provided to personally pay for his flight and quarantine, she added.
“Mr. Smith rejected each provides and selected to stay within the Dominican Republic,” she mentioned. Smith, for his half, mentioned he did not obtain any wide-ranging provide to cowl all his bills.
CBC Information has requested each side to supply documentation to again up their claims: together with a request for Smith to share the e-mail that might present he was fired for no obvious motive, and for Enviroshake to share proof of the corporate’s provides to Smith to pay for his journey residence.
Enviroshake wouldn’t, saying the provide “was made within the context of [an] ongoing settlement dialogue.”
Smith solely despatched sections of his correspondence with the corporate and never full paperwork. One screenshot he shared says Enviroshake would provide a $1,500 stipend for quarantine lodging upon returning to Canada, however Smith says that supply was contingent on him agreeing to overly restrictive non-disclosure and non-compete clauses.
He alleged these agreements amounted to his by no means talking about being fired and agreeing to not work within the trade or the territory the place he had developed enterprise contacts.
‘I simply needed to assist my buddy’
All of this turmoil was information to Dave Murray, a Toronto-based illustrator who launched the GoFundMe marketing campaign in an effort to get Smith residence. He instructed CBC Information in a sequence of emails that he knew nothing about Enviroshake’s claims, nor did he know that Smith’s father was the president of the corporate.
“I simply needed to assist my buddy,” he mentioned.
Although he wasn’t initially requested about any household ties with Enviroshake, Smith additionally didn’t inform a reporter that his father was the corporate’s president throughout his preliminary interview with CBC Information. When pressed on that omission in subsequent messages, Smith mentioned it “did not come to [his] thoughts as being related,” as his father wasn’t concerned in his employment.
Enviroshake, in the meantime, maintained that Patrick Smith was concerned in his son’s hiring and conscious of the corporate’s choice to fireplace him. The corporate additionally mentioned Smith acquired directions from his father throughout Ashley Smith’s maternity go away.
Smith mentioned he hasn’t spoken to his father since he was fired.
CBC Information requested an interview with Smith’s father. He as a substitute despatched an emailed assertion.
“As with every Enviroshake worker who travels Internationally for work, Corbin’s flight and quarantine bills will likely be lined by Enviroshake upon his presentation of legitimate receipts,” Patrick Smith mentioned.
Corbin Smith mentioned nobody from the corporate has communicated that supply to him.
Murray mentioned he began the GoFundMe of his personal accord, and was not requested by Smith to take action. He suspended donations after being offered with the corporate’s aspect of the story by CBC Information.
He mentioned the cash that has already been raised can be utilized for Smith’s present keep at a federally mandated quarantine resort in Toronto, assist pay down his debt incurred whereas within the Caribbean, and for issues like changing garments Smith misplaced to a bedbug infestation within the hostel the place he had been staying.
However it’s clear that Murray feels he wasn’t offered with your entire story.
“I began the GoFundMe marketing campaign to assist Corbin, my buddy, get residence safely. Having communicated with him throughout his time within the Dominican, I solely grew extra involved for his bodily and psychological well being, and at occasions, really feared Corbin wouldn’t make it residence alive,” he mentioned.
“At no level was I conscious that Corbin’s dad was the president of Enviroshake. Discovering that out was surprising, and I used to be — and nonetheless am — upset with Corbin for not sharing that info with me once I was establishing the fundraiser.
“Regardless of this, I’m completely satisfied my buddy is again in Toronto, safely, the place he can get the remedy and assist he wants.”
GoFundMe says donors are protected
Smith mentioned that remedy is for a debilitating well being subject. He instructed CBC Information that he spent a lot of his time within the Dominican Republic unsuccessfully making an attempt to entry his drugs, which is taken into account a managed substance in that nation.
“My greatest hurdle has been my well being,” he mentioned in his preliminary interview.
When contacted concerning the crowdfunding marketing campaign and requested in a normal sense what occurs when there are points surrounding one, GoFundMe spokesperson Amy Williams mentioned that the corporate takes all complaints severely.
“If a misuse of funds takes place on GoFundMe, donors are protected and their donations are refunded,” she mentioned.
The corporate’s web site additionally states that donors are capable of submit a declare for a refund.